Home›Guidance›Staking & Yield
Staking & Yield

Crypto Staking and "Earn" Programs: The Risks Nobody Explains

What you actually agree to with staking and "earn" programs, where the risk sits, and how to evaluate an offer.

This guide is general education. It is not financial or legal advice. Talk to a licensed professional about your own situation.

"Earn 5% on your crypto." Offers like this sound like a savings account. In 2022, hundreds of thousands of people learned that they are not. When Celsius, Voyager, BlockFi and FTX failed, customers who thought they were earning a little extra found that their deposits were frozen, and in some cases that the deposits legally belonged to the company.

This guide explains what you are actually agreeing to, where the risk sits, and how to evaluate any staking or yield offer before you deposit.

Two very different things are both called "staking"

Protocol-level staking

Proof-of-stake blockchains such as Ethereum use staked coins to secure the network. Validators lock up coins and receive newly issued rewards for helping confirm transactions. The rewards come from the protocol itself, not from a company lending your coins out.

The risks are real, but they are specific:

  • Slashing. A validator that breaks consensus rules can have part of its stake destroyed.
  • Lockups and exit queues. You may not be able to withdraw immediately.
  • Price risk. Rewards are paid in the same volatile asset.

Liquid staking (pooled staking that gives you a tradeable token representing your stake) adds more risk. Ethereum.org notes that liquid staking tokens "inherit the underlying risks of staking" and "add layers of their own." These include smart-contract bugs, slashing losses spread across all token holders, and counterparty risk: if the provider "becomes insolvent or freezes withdrawals, there is nothing onchain for you to redeem."

In May 2025, SEC staff said that certain protocol staking arrangements, including solo staking and some custodial staking, are administrative or ministerial activities rather than securities offerings. That statement concerns how the activity is regulated. It does not say staking is safe.

Custodial "earn," "yield" or "interest" programs

With a custodial program, you hand your crypto to a company, and the company pays you a rate. How the company generates that rate is up to the company. It may lend your coins to trading firms, post them as collateral, deploy them in DeFi, or borrow against them.

The SEC's 2022 investor bulletin on these accounts warned that, although they "may sound similar" to bank accounts, they are "not as safe as bank or credit union deposits." It listed the risk "that the company holding your crypto assets might fail or go bankrupt."

Even when an exchange's "staking" product really is protocol staking, you still carry custody risk. In a 2023 settlement, the SEC said that customers who hand tokens to staking-as-a-service providers "lose control of those tokens and take on risks associated with those platforms."

Rehypothecation: your deposit becomes someone else's collateral

Rehypothecation means the platform reuses your assets. It lends them out, pledges them as collateral, or borrows against them, sometimes to raise cash (fiat) loans for its own operations.

Celsius's terms of use were unusually explicit about this. The court record quotes them. Customers granted Celsius "all right and title" to Earn deposits, and Celsius could "lend, sell, pledge, hypothecate, assign, invest, use, commingle or otherwise dispose of" them.

What Celsius did with the money:

  • Unsecured loans. The FTC alleged that Celsius issued unsecured loans totaling $1.2 billion as of April 2022, even though it had told customers it made only safe, secured loans.
  • A fake insurance policy. Celsius claimed a $750 million insurance policy for deposits that did not exist.
  • Criminal convictions. Founder Alex Mashinsky pleaded guilty to commodities and securities fraud and was sentenced to 12 years in prison in 2025.

At FTX, the SEC alleged that customer funds were diverted to an affiliated trading firm, Alameda Research. The firm had a "virtually unlimited 'line of credit' funded by the platform's customers." FTX's app had also advertised yield on customer balances.

The risk/return mismatch

Hypothetical example (illustrative only): You deposit $75,000 in a program paying 0.4% a year. You earn about $300 a year. Meanwhile, the platform may be lending out your coins or borrowing against them.

  • If things go well, the platform keeps most of the upside from using your $75,000.
  • If things go badly (a borrower defaults, markets crash, customers rush for the exits), you could lose some or all of the $75,000.

Your upside is capped at $300. Your downside is the full deposit. The customer carries most of the risk while earning a small fraction of the reward.

Higher rates do not fix this. They usually mean the platform takes more risk to pay them. Celsius advertised Earn rates as high as 18% APY, according to the FTC.

How a "bank run" happens without a bank

A crypto lender that has lent or pledged customer assets does not have all of those assets on hand. As long as few people withdraw at once, this is not visible. When a shock arrives, withdrawals spike and the gap shows.

  • Voyager. In June 2022, Voyager issued a default notice to the hedge fund Three Arrows Capital over a loan worth more than $650 million. Voyager filed for bankruptcy in early July.
  • Celsius. Celsius froze withdrawals on June 12, 2022. It filed for bankruptcy a month later, reporting about $4.3 billion in assets against $5.5 billion in liabilities, a shortfall of roughly $1.2 billion.
  • BlockFi. BlockFi halted withdrawals after FTX collapsed, disclosed "significant exposure" to FTX, and filed for Chapter 11 on November 28, 2022.

No government deposit insurance covered these programs. Voyager told customers their funds were FDIC-insured. The FDIC and the Federal Reserve issued a cease-and-desist letter, noting that Voyager itself was not FDIC-insured and that customers "would not receive insurance coverage in the event of Voyager's failure." The FTC later alleged that Voyager's customers lost more than $1 billion in crypto.

What you become in bankruptcy: often an unsecured creditor

In January 2023, Judge Martin Glenn of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York ruled that crypto in Celsius Earn accounts (about $4.2 billion) was property of the bankruptcy estate, not of the customers. Why: the terms of use transferred ownership. Earn customers became unsecured creditors. They stood in line with other creditors instead of simply taking back "their" coins.

Account type made a difference. In the BlockFi case, the court found that assets in custodial wallet accounts belonged to customers. It treated interest-account (BIA) holders differently, because they had accepted risk in exchange for yield. Even the returned wallet assets remained subject to possible clawback claims.

Other realities of crypto bankruptcy:

  • Claims may be fixed at the filing date. FTX valued customer claims in dollars as of its November 11, 2022 petition date. Customers were repaid based on those prices, not on later crypto prices.
  • It takes years. Celsius froze withdrawals in June 2022. Its plan did not take effect until January 31, 2024.
  • Scammers target creditors. After a 2023 breach at Kroll, the claims agent for FTX, BlockFi and Genesis, creditors received phishing emails impersonating the bankruptcy process to steal wallet seed phrases.

Checklist: questions to ask before you deposit

  1. Who holds the private keys? If the platform holds them, you carry counterparty risk.
  2. What do the terms say about ownership? Search the terms of service for "title," "ownership," "rehypothecate," "pledge," "lend," and "commingle." If you grant the platform title to your assets, assume you could become an unsecured creditor.
  3. Where does the yield come from? Is it protocol rewards (and on which network), lending (to whom, and secured how), or trading? If they cannot explain it clearly, walk away.
  4. Reserves compared with liabilities. A "proof of reserves" snapshot is not an audit. The PCAOB (the U.S. auditing standards board) warns that such reports likely do not address liabilities or whether the assets were borrowed, and cover only one point in time.
  5. Regulatory status. Check the specific entity, in your state, with state and federal regulators. A license for one activity, such as money transmission, does not cover lending your assets.
  6. Withdrawal terms. Look for lockups, unbonding periods, notice periods, and the platform's right to pause withdrawals at its discretion.
  7. Insurance claims. Ask what exactly is insured, by whom, up to what limit, and against which events. FDIC insurance does not cover crypto, and it does not protect you against the failure of a non-bank company.
  8. Is the reward worth the risk? Compare the dollar yield with the amount you could lose (see the hypothetical above).

Warning signs of a risky staking or earn program

  • Rates well above what the underlying network pays, or "guaranteed" returns
  • Claims of being "safer than a bank," "no risk," or FDIC-insured
  • Bonus rates for locking funds longer, or for holding the platform's own token
  • Vague answers about who borrows your assets
  • Sudden rate changes, new withdrawal limits, or delayed withdrawals "for maintenance"
  • Executives reassuring customers loudly while withdrawals slow down

What to do if a crypto platform freezes withdrawals

  1. Document everything now. Take screenshots of balances, transaction history, deposit addresses and account settings. Download statements and save the current and past terms of service (the Internet Archive can help). Keep all emails and support tickets.
  2. Do not send more money. A demand for fees to "unlock" withdrawals is a hallmark of fraud. The CFTC warns that fraudsters often direct investors to pay additional costs, such as purported taxes, to withdraw "profits."
  3. Report it. File complaints with the FBI's IC3 (ic3.gov), your state securities or financial regulator, and the FTC or CFPB as appropriate.
  4. Follow the official bankruptcy process. If the company files, find the court-appointed claims agent through the court docket. Check your scheduled claim and file a proof of claim before the deadline. Watch for notices about disputed claims and preference (clawback) actions.
  5. Assume every "recovery" offer is a scam until proven otherwise. The FBI reports that recovery scams cost victims $1.4 billion in 2025, and it has warned about fake law firms that target crypto victims. IC3 says it will never ask for payment to recover lost funds or refer you to a company that does. Legitimate claims go through the court process, and no one can guarantee recovery.
  6. Get qualified help. A bankruptcy or securities attorney can advise on your claim. Where assets were moved on-chain before or after the collapse, blockchain tracing can document where they went, for creditors, trustees or law enforcement.

ChainWatch is a blockchain-forensics firm. We do not provide investment, legal or tax advice. If you have lost funds to a failed platform or a scam, report it to ic3.gov first.

Staking and earn programs: common questions

Is crypto staking safe?

It depends on which kind. Protocol-level staking carries specific risks: slashing, lockups and price swings. Custodial “earn” or “yield” programs add the risk that the company holding your crypto lends it out, fails or goes bankrupt. SEC staff’s 2025 statement about how some staking is regulated does not say staking is safe.

Are crypto earn accounts FDIC insured?

No. FDIC insurance does not cover crypto, and it does not protect you if a non-bank company fails. The SEC has warned that these accounts are “not as safe as bank or credit union deposits.” No government deposit insurance covered Celsius, Voyager or BlockFi customers.

What happens to my crypto if the platform goes bankrupt?

It depends on the terms you agreed to. In the Celsius case, the court ruled that crypto in Earn accounts belonged to the bankruptcy estate, so those customers became unsecured creditors. In BlockFi, custodial wallet assets were found to belong to customers, but interest-account holders were treated differently. Claims can take years and may be valued at the filing date.

The platform froze withdrawals and says I must pay a fee to unlock them. Should I?

No. A demand for fees to unlock withdrawals is a hallmark of fraud. Document everything, report it to IC3 and your state regulator, and, if the company files for bankruptcy, follow the court’s official claims process.

Sources

The information on this page was checked against the sources listed in September 2026. Laws, agency guidance, company policies and contact details change, so please verify the current information with the original source before you act.

More from the guidance library

Bitcoin ATM ScamsBitcoin ATM Scams: Why No One Legit Sends You to One

Scammers direct people to feed cash into crypto ATMs (kiosks) and scan a QR code that sends the money straight to the criminal.

Fake Crypto Trading Platform ScamsFake Crypto Trading Platform Scams: How to Spot Them

Scammers steer people to fake crypto exchanges or apps that show made-up profits, then take every deposit.

Crypto Recovery ScamsCrypto Recovery Scams: Fake Lawyers, Agents and Firms

Scammers target people who already lost crypto, posing as lawyers, recovery firms, or law enforcement who can get the money back for a fee.